How Do You Reheat a Chicken Pot Pie Without Drying It Out in Colorado Springs?
Last updated: November 20, 2026
Jump to: Key takeaways | Why it dries out here | Oven steps | How long at 350 degrees | Microwave | From frozen | Already cooked or Take ‘n Bake
To reheat a chicken pot pie without drying it out, cover it loosely with foil and warm it in a 350°F oven. Take the foil off for the last few minutes so the crust crisps. It’s ready when a food thermometer in the center reads 165°F, the temperature established by federal food safety guidelines for reheated leftovers.
Colorado Springs sits at 6,035 feet. FSIS’s high-altitude guidance says moisture evaporates quickly above 2,500 feet, and covering food during cooking helps it keep its moisture.
At our sweet and savory pie cafe on Centennial Blvd in Colorado Springs, we serve chicken pot pies hot from the kitchen or as Take ‘n Bake pies for your oven, and we make every dish from scratch. If you have a question about a pie you bought from us, contact us.
Disclaimer: This guide is general information based on federal food safety guidance and published reheating guides. Menus change, so check our online menu before you order, and if you have a food allergy, ask us about ingredients.
Key Takeaways
To reheat a chicken pot pie well, keep moisture in while the center gets hot enough. The points below come from federal food safety guidance from USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) and FoodSafety.gov, along with two published reheating guides, plus the one local detail that changes things in Colorado Springs: the city’s elevation.
- Cover the pie to reheat it. FSIS says covering leftovers keeps moisture in and helps the food heat all the way through.
- Reheat until a food thermometer in the center reads 165°F, the leftovers temperature on both FSIS and FoodSafety.gov.
- The City of Colorado Springs lists its elevation as 6,035 feet, and FSIS says moisture evaporates quickly above 2,500 feet.
- Balancing Motherhood’s oven method for a refrigerated pot pie takes about 30 to 40 minutes at 350°F, with the foil off for the last part.
- Our menu lists Rosemary’s Baby, Take and Bake, and Chicken Curry Take & Bake, which go in your oven for their first bake.
Why Pot Pie Can Dry Out Faster in Colorado Springs
Pot pie can dry out faster in Colorado Springs because the city sits well above 2,500 feet, the altitude where FSIS says the atmosphere becomes much drier. The City of Colorado Springs lists its elevation as 6,035 feet, and at that height, FSIS says, moisture evaporates quickly from everything.

FSIS guidance on high altitude cooking also notes that high-altitude areas tend toward low humidity, which can make the moisture in foods evaporate more quickly during cooking. Two habits from the same FSIS page can help with a pot pie:
- Keep it covered while it heats. FSIS says covering food during cooking helps it hold on to moisture.
- Use a food thermometer. FSIS warns that at high altitude it’s easy to overcook poultry or scorch a casserole, and it recommends a thermometer to avoid dry food.
How to Warm Up a Cold Pot Pie in the Oven, Step by Step
To warm up a cold pot pie in the oven, heat the oven to 350°F and bake the pie under a loose foil tent until the filling is hot. Then take the foil off so the crust crisps again. The pie is done when a food thermometer in the center reads 165°F, as the steps below explain.
- Check how long it sat out. FSIS says to throw away perishable food left at room temperature for more than 2 hours, or more than 1 hour when it’s over 90°F.
- Heat the oven to 350°F. Erin Clarke, founder of Well Plated, uses that temperature in her advice to Food Republic, and so does the Balancing Motherhood guide.
- Tent the pie loosely with foil. Clarke told Food Republic she recommends tenting the pie loosely “to keep the top from getting too dark.” FSIS leftovers guidance says covering holds in moisture and helps the food heat all the way through.
- Bake until the filling is hot. The timing section below shows the ranges that both guides use.
- Uncover for the last few minutes. Clarke and Balancing Motherhood both take the foil off at the end to crisp the crust.
- Check the center for 165°F. For casseroles and other combination dishes, FSIS says to put the thermometer in the thickest part or center, so push it through the crust into the filling.
Clarke also suggests letting the pie come to room temperature before it goes in the oven, so the center heats faster and the crust is less likely to overbrown. If you do, keep it inside the 2-hour limit in step 1.
Our menu also offers a Gravy 12 oz side. FSIS says to reheat gravy by bringing it to a rolling boil.
How Long to Reheat a Pot Pie in the Oven at 350°F?
A refrigerated chicken pot pie takes about 30 to 40 minutes at 350°F in the Balancing Motherhood method: 25 to 30 minutes under foil, then 5 to 10 minutes uncovered. Erin Clarke told Food Republic to try 350°F for 15 to 20 minutes for a slice, and she recommended 30 to 35 minutes for the whole pie plate.
| Guide | What goes in the oven | Time |
|---|---|---|
| Balancing Motherhood | Refrigerated chicken pot pie | 25 to 30 minutes covered with foil at 350°F, then 5 to 10 minutes uncovered |
| Erin Clarke, to Food Republic | Whole pie plate | 30 to 35 minutes (temperature not stated) |
| Erin Clarke, to Food Republic | Single slice | 15 to 20 minutes at 350°F |
Clarke’s slice needs about half the time of a whole pie, and Balancing Motherhood says a frozen pie needs longer than a refrigerated one.
The FSIS pages we read give no reheating time for pot pie. For oven-roasting meat and poultry, FSIS recommends that cooks use sea-level times and temperatures because altitude doesn’t affect oven temperatures. For leftovers, the federal target is a temperature of 165°F, as listed on the FoodSafety.gov safe minimum internal temperature chart.
How to Reheat Chicken Pot Pie in the Microwave
To reheat chicken pot pie in the microwave, follow the FSIS steps for leftovers listed below and keep heating until a food thermometer reads 165°F in several spots. Microwaves have cold spots, which is why FSIS asks for more than one reading. Expect a softer crust than the oven gives.
- Use a microwave-safe glass or ceramic dish with a cover. Add a little liquid if the food needs it.
- Vent the lid or wrap so steam can escape.
- Rotate the dish partway through for even heating.
- Let the food rest, then check the temperature in several places for 165°F.
Balancing Motherhood says, “the microwave isn’t great for getting your crust nice and crispy,” and our guide to finding good quiche in Colorado Springs warns that a microwave softens a quiche crust, too.
FSIS says microwave cooking may take less time at high altitude because liquids evaporate faster, with exceptions such as meat and poultry, which require the maximum cooking time. Let the thermometer reading tell you when your pot pie is done.
How to Reheat Frozen Chicken Pot Pie
You can reheat a frozen leftover chicken pot pie without thawing it first. FSIS says it’s safe to reheat frozen leftovers, including casseroles and combination meals, in the oven or microwave without thawing. Reheating takes longer than it would for thawed food, so keep the pie covered and check the center for 165°F before serving.
If you’d rather thaw it first, FSIS lists the refrigerator, cold water, and the microwave as safe ways to do it. Food thawed in the microwave should keep heating until it reaches 165°F.
Before you freeze or reheat leftovers, check how long they’ve been in the fridge, and use the storage times for leftover pot pie in our guide to how many people a chicken pot pie feeds.
How Do I Reheat an Already Cooked Chicken Pot Pie?
You reheat an already cooked chicken pot pie with the oven steps above until the center reads 165°F on a food thermometer. In our homepage’s words, our Take ‘n Bake pies are “pre-made and ready to bake fresh in your oven,” so they go in for their first bake. Ask us for baking times when you pick one up.

These chicken Take ‘n Bake pies can be ordered on our online menu:
- Rosemary’s Baby, Take and Bake: slow-roasted chicken, peas, and carrots in white wine rosemary béchamel, $14.99
- Chicken Curry Take & Bake: $14.99
Prices are from our online menu on November 19, 2026, and can change. Check the menu when you order.
If you’d rather have a hot pot pie, our menu has both chicken and beef. Our list of what to serve with chicken pot pie pairs Mashers with Cluck n’ Shrooms and a House (Simple) side salad with Rosemary’s Baby. For beef, Julia’s Child, the pot pie made with beef bourguignon on our hot menu, is one of the pies in our roundup of meat pies in Colorado Springs.
Our hours are Sunday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m., Tuesday and Wednesday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m., and Thursday to Saturday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., and we’re closed on Mondays.
For questions about reheating one of our pies, call us at (719) 314-6172. We may not answer calls at busy times.
For the fastest service, order a hot or Take ‘n Bake pot pie online for pickup at 5152 Centennial Blvd.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.