Title Image

Blog

Popular holiday pies in Colorado Springs graphic - 3.14 Pi Bar

The Most Popular Holiday Pies in Colorado Springs and Where to Order Them

This guide covers what ends up on holiday tables and which pies you can order whole from our Colorado Springs pie restaurant.

At 3.14 Pi Bar, we make sweet pies from scratch and sell them by the slice, as well as Cutie Pies and whole pies. Call (719) 314-6172 to ask about holiday orders, or get in touch with us in Colorado Springs online.

Disclaimer: This article offers general information. Our pie lineup, holiday order dates, and daily availability can change, so check with us before you plan your order.

Key Takeaways

  • Instacart’s purchase data ranks pumpkin, apple and pecan as the top three Thanksgiving pies in the United States.
  • Sweet potato and cherry complete the national top five.
  • The day before Thanksgiving is the biggest pie-buying day of the year, so order early.
  • 3.14 Pi Bar’s online menu lists ten whole pies: five fruit and nut pies and five cream pies.
  • Baked pumpkin and pecan pies keep 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator, according to FoodSafety.gov.

What Are the Most Popular Holiday Pies?

The most popular Thanksgiving pies in the United States are pumpkin, apple, pecan, sweet potato and cherry, in that order. The ranking comes from Instacart’s analysis of its 2024 Thanksgiving pie orders, published in November 2025. Berry and peanut butter pies also made its top ten.

National rank Pie On our whole-pie menu
1 Pumpkin Ask us about seasonal pies
2 Apple Caramel Apple
3 Pecan Black Bottom Bourbon Pecan
4 Sweet potato Ask us about seasonal pies
5 Cherry Amaretto Cherry

 

The data covers grocery orders, so it measures what people buy to serve at home. It doesn’t count pies baked from scratch or picked up from a restaurant.

The Top Five Holiday Pies, One by One

Each of the five does a different job on the dessert table. Here’s what you’re choosing between.

  • Pumpkin is a spiced custard pie with a single bottom crust. It’s the one most guests expect to see in November.
  • Apple is a double-crust fruit pie, served warm or at room temperature. Ours is the Caramel Apple.
  • Pecan has a sweet, dense filling under a layer of toasted nuts. Ours is the Black Bottom Bourbon Pecan.
  • Sweet potato looks a lot like pumpkin, and bakers make it the same way, as a spiced custard. Instacart found its strongest following in the South.
  • Cherry brings a tart fruit pie to a table full of rich ones. Ours is the Amaretto Cherry.

If you’re deciding on the most popular pies for Thanksgiving dinner, start with one from the top three. Then add a second pie that tastes nothing like the first.

Popular Thanksgiving Pies by Region

Tastes shift from one part of the country to another. Instacart found these patterns in its order data:

  • The West: pumpkin leads, with California, Oregon, and Washington out front.
  • The South: pecan pie was popular across Texas, Mississippi, and Oklahoma, and sweet potato pie in Georgia, Maryland, and North Carolina.
  • The Midwest: French silk pie stood out in Illinois, Iowa, and Missouri.
  • The Northeast: cream pies topped the charts in Maine and Massachusetts.

Instacart didn’t publish a Colorado figure. The Western result is the closest we have, making pumpkin the safe first pick for a Colorado Springs table.

Popular Christmas Pies and Winter Favorites

Instacart didn’t publish a separate ranking of the most popular Christmas pies. Its data shows the same top five rising again in late December, in a smaller wave than Thanksgiving.

If you served pumpkin and pecan in November, December is a chance to change it up. A cream pie next to a fruit pie gives the table two very different desserts. These are the whole cream pies on our online menu:

  • Key Lime
  • Lemon PI
  • Nutella Italian Silk
  • Cookies and Dream
  • Nutty Professor

Fruit Pie or Cream Pie: How to Choose for Your Table

The most popular holiday pies fall into two groups, and a table with one of each covers most guests. This table shows how the two groups differ.

Fruit and nut pies Cream pies
Our whole pies Amaretto Cherry, Blueberry Fields, Son of a Peach, Caramel Apple, Black Bottom Bourbon Pecan Cookies and Dream, Nutella Italian Silk, Nutty Professor, Key Lime, Lemon PI
How to serve At room temperature or warmed Cold, straight from the refrigerator
Good for Guests who want the classics Guests who want something lighter after a big dinner
On the drive home Keep the box level Keep the pie cold until you serve it

 

For storage, FoodSafety.gov’s Cold Food Storage Chart gives baked pumpkin and pecan pies 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator and 1 to 2 months in the freezer. It gives custard and chiffon pies 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator and says not to freeze them.

How Many Holiday Pies to Order

Work through these steps before you call.

  1. Count your guests, then count the desserts other people are bringing.
  2. Choose one pie from the national top three to cover the traditionalists.
  3. Add a second pie in a different style. Pick a cream pie if the first is fruit.
  4. For a mixed crowd, add a Cutie Pack, which lets you choose four Cutie Pies.
  5. Ask us how many slices a whole pie gives when you order, and round up if you want leftovers.

Holiday Pies in Colorado Springs at 3.14 Pi Bar

We make our pies from scratch at 5152 Centennial Blvd. Our online menu lists ten whole pies, and these five line up with the national favorites:

  • For apple: Caramel Apple
  • For pecan: Black Bottom Bourbon Pecan
  • For cherry: Amaretto Cherry
  • For berry: Blueberry Fields
  • For something off the usual list: Son of a Peach

The online menu also has a Thanksgiving section with family-size mac and cheese, Brussels sprouts, and mashers. For brunch the morning after, our guide to the best quiche in Colorado Springs covers the savory side.

If you have a food allergy, tell our staff before you order. Pie names don’t list every ingredient.

When and How to Order Your Holiday Pie

Order early. Instacart found that the day before Thanksgiving is the biggest pie-buying day of the year, and a smaller rush follows in late December.

  • Call (719) 314-6172 to ask about this year’s holiday order dates.
  • Tell us which whole pies you want and the day you’d like to pick up.
  • Pick up at 5152 Centennial Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80919.

Outside the holiday rush, you can order pie for pickup in Colorado Springs from our regular online menu.

Reserve Your Holiday Pies in Colorado Springs

Pick one pie from the top three and add a second you’re curious about. Then call us at (719) 314-6172 and we’ll tell you what we’re baking this season.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the number one selling pie at Thanksgiving?

Pumpkin. Instacart’s analysis of its 2024 Thanksgiving orders ranks pumpkin first in the United States, with apple second and pecan third. Sweet potato and cherry complete the top five.

What are the most popular holiday pies in Colorado Springs?

We couldn’t find a ranking for Colorado Springs alone. The nearest measure is Instacart’s national data, which shows pumpkin leading in the West. Apple and pecan follow it nationally.

Which pies are most popular at Christmas?

The same ones as Thanksgiving. Instacart’s data shows the top five pies rising again in late December, in a smaller wave. Add a cream pie if you want variety.

How far ahead should I order a holiday pie?

As early as you can. The day before Thanksgiving is the biggest pie-buying day of the year, so waiting until that week is a risk. Call 3.14 Pi Bar at (719) 314-6172 for this year’s order dates.

How long does a holiday pie keep?

FoodSafety.gov lists 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator for baked pumpkin and pecan pies and the same for custard and chiffon pies. Pumpkin and pecan can be frozen for 1 to 2 months. Custard and chiffon pies shouldn’t be frozen.

Written by 3.14 Pi Bar

Last updated: October 9, 2026

 

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.