Who Makes the Best Meat Pie in Colorado Springs?
Last updated: November 10, 2026
The best meat pie in Colorado Springs depends on the kind you want: a hot pot pie with gravy, an empanada, a sausage roll or a shepherd’s pie under mashed potatoes. This guide covers where to find each one in town, starting with the pot pies we bake at 3.14 Pi Bar.
We’re a pie cafe in Colorado Springs at 5152 Centennial Blvd, and savory pies are a big part of our menu. Call (719) 314-6172 or send us a message with questions about today’s pies.
Disclaimer: This guide is general information. Menus and prices for every place listed can change, and details about other businesses come from their websites as of October 22, 2026, so confirm with each one before you go.
In This Guide
- Meat Pies in Colorado Springs Compared
- Three Kinds of Meat Pie to Choose From
- 3.14 Pi Bar: Seven Meat Pot Pies on Our Menu
- Empanadas: Norma’s Bakery
- Sausage Rolls: Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery and The British Pantry
- Shepherd’s Pie: Jack Quinn’s Irish Pub
- Order a Meat Pie From 3.14 Pi Bar
- Frequently Asked Questions
Key Takeaways
- 3.14 Pi Bar on Centennial Blvd lists seven meat pot pies on its online menu, each $14.99, and each is also listed as a Take & Bake pie for your oven.
- Norma’s Bakery on N Academy Blvd sells a chicken empanada.
- Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery on E Fillmore St sells sausage rolls, including frozen ones to bake at home.
- The British Pantry and Tea Room serves a sausage roll as part of its afternoon tea.
- Jack Quinn’s Irish Pub downtown serves a beef shepherd’s pie.
Meat Pies in Colorado Springs Compared
Here’s how the five places line up by the style of meat pie each one sells. The table lists each address, the kind of meat pie on the menu and the price posted online. Details come from each business’s website on October 22, 2026, and from our online menu on November 5, 2026, so check before you go.
| Place | Address | Meat pie style | Listed price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3.14 Pi Bar | 5152 Centennial Blvd | Seven meat pot pies, each also as Take & Bake | $14.99 each |
| Norma’s Bakery | 2367 N Academy Blvd | Chicken empanada | $8.99 |
| Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery | 610 E Fillmore St | Sausage rolls, fresh or frozen | $3.85 |
| The British Pantry and Tea Room | 2403 W Colorado Ave | Sausage roll with afternoon tea | Part of afternoon tea |
| Jack Quinn’s Irish Pub | 21 S Tejon St | Beef shepherd’s pie | $17 to $18 |
If you’re planning a day out, our guide to where to eat near Garden of the Gods covers more places around the park.
Three Kinds of Meat Pie to Choose From
Before you pick a place, decide which kind of meat pie you’re craving: one you can hold in your hand and eat on the go, a rich pub pie served hot at the table, or a pot pie with the filling baked under a crust. There are three kinds of meat pie:
- Australian and New Zealand style: handheld pies made to grab and go, with a sturdy crust and a savory filling.
- British pub pies: pies like steak and ale, rich and slow-cooked, served hot at the table.
- Pot pies: hearty pies with the filling baked under a crust, the kind we make at 3.14 Pi Bar.

This guide covers the meat pies we could confirm on Colorado Springs menus: pot pies, empanadas, sausage rolls, and shepherd’s pie. For something sweet after, our guide to the most popular holiday pies in Colorado Springs covers where to order them.
3.14 Pi Bar: Seven Meat Pot Pies on Our Menu
At 3.14 Pi Bar, pie is the center of the menu, savory and sweet, and every dish is made from scratch. On November 5, 2026, our online menu listed seven pot pies with meat, each $14.99, from Irish stew to beef bourguignon to pork green chili.
Meat pot pies on the 3.14 Pi Bar menu

- Julia’s Child: beef bourguignon with tender beef, mushrooms, carrots, and onions simmered in red wine.
- Guinness Sakes!: Irish stew with ground beef, carrots, and potatoes in a rich Guinness gravy.
- Rosemary’s Baby: chicken, peas, and carrots in a creamy white wine and rosemary bechamel.
- Cluck n’ Shrooms: braised chicken, spinach, mushrooms, and onions in a creamy Swiss bechamel, served over chicken gravy.
- Not So Gringo: our flaky crust stuffed with pork green chili and served over more green chili.
- Chicken Curry Savory Pie: pulled chicken in a mild red curry sauce with onion, served over a homemade masala sauce.
- Southwest: green chilies, black beans, roasted corn, tomatoes, and onions over pork or vegetarian green chile, topped with sour cream.
Some items on our online menu can show as unavailable, so check it before you go. If someone at your table skips meat, the Veg Out pot pie has potatoes, peas, carrots, and onions in a creamy bechamel.
Take & Bake meat pies for your oven
Our Take & Bake pot pies come pre-made and ready to bake fresh in your oven. On November 5, 2026, the online menu listed Take & Bake versions of all seven, each $14.99.
Prices can change, so call us to confirm.
If you’re feeding a group, our guide to how many people a chicken pot pie feeds helps you work out how many to order.
Empanadas: Norma’s Bakery
For a handheld meat pie, Norma’s Bakery at 2367 N Academy Blvd lists a chicken empanada on its menu for $8.99. Its menu describes it as a golden-brown pastry filled with seasoned chicken and a blend of savory spices. It fits the handheld style, closer to a grab-and-go pie than a pot pie.
Sausage Rolls: Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery and The British Pantry
Two shops on our list sell sausage rolls: a Dutch bakery with an online shop and a British shop with a tea room. Boonzaaijer’s sells them fresh or frozen to bake at home, while The British Pantry serves one as part of its afternoon tea, so the better pick depends on whether you want takeout or a sit-down treat.
Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery
Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery at 610 E Fillmore St sells sausage rolls in the savory section of its online shop. It’s also one of the shops in our guide to the best bakeries in Colorado Springs.
- Fresh sausage rolls: $3.85 each.
- Frozen sausage rolls: sold raw, with baking instructions for your oven.
The British Pantry and Tea Room
The British Pantry and Tea Room at 2403 W Colorado Ave includes a freshly baked sausage roll in its afternoon tea, along with finger sandwiches, scones with clotted cream and jam, and desserts. The tea room is open Saturday and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m., and its website says reservations are required.
Shepherd’s Pie: Jack Quinn’s Irish Pub
Jack Quinn’s Irish Pub at 21 S Tejon St in downtown Colorado Springs lists a shepherd’s pie on its menu. It’s made with ground beef, carrots, onions, mushrooms, and peas, topped with champ potatoes and cheddar, and served with Irish soda bread and honey butter.
The menu also lists a version served in a locally made sourdough bread bowl. Prices on its menu page run from $17 to $18, depending on the version.
Order a Meat Pie From 3.14 Pi Bar
For the fastest service, place your carryout order online, since we may not answer calls during busy times. Order a pot pie from 3.14 Pi Bar for pickup at 5152 Centennial Blvd, hot for tonight or as a Take & Bake for later.
If you want something lighter alongside it, our guide to the best quiche in Colorado Springs covers it.
Our Take & Bake pies come frozen, pre-made, and ready to bake fresh in your oven whenever you’re ready. With a hot pot pie, you can add a House (Simple) side salad or a side of fries from our online menu.
We’re open Tuesday through Sunday and closed on Mondays. Hours run from 11 AM to 8 PM on Sunday, Tuesday, and Wednesday, and from 11 AM to 9 PM Thursday to Saturday.
Some of our pies rotate as specials and come and go from the menu, so check the online menu on the day you order. On November 10, 2026, it showed Rosemary’s Baby, Cluck n’ Shrooms, and Not So Gringo ready to order hot. The Take & Bake pies were listed that day but not open for orders, so check the menu before you plan around one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who makes the best meat pie in Colorado Springs?
It depends on the style you want. 3.14 Pi Bar on Centennial Blvd lists seven meat pot pies on its online menu, Norma’s Bakery sells a chicken empanada, Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery and The British Pantry sell sausage rolls, and Jack Quinn’s Irish Pub serves a beef shepherd’s pie.
Where can I buy a meat pie to bake at home in Colorado Springs?
3.14 Pi Bar sells Take & Bake pot pies, including Julia’s Child and Cluck n’ Shrooms, that come pre-made and ready to bake in your oven. Boonzaaijer’s Dutch Bakery sells frozen sausage rolls that come raw with baking instructions.
Does 3.14 Pi Bar have a vegetarian pot pie?
Yes. The Veg Out pot pie has potatoes, peas, carrots, and onions in a creamy bechamel, and the Southwest pot pie can be served over vegetarian green chile.
How much is a meat pot pie at 3.14 Pi Bar?
On November 5, 2026, our online menu listed each meat pot pie at $14.99, hot or as a Take & Bake. Prices can change, so call us to confirm.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.